Strife Versus Stasis: The Paradox of Achilles in Hades

Yahyapour, Fatemeh Sadat

doi:10.22034/ijpie.2023.185570

Strife Versus Stasis: The Paradox of Achilles in Hades

Document Type : Original Article

Author

Fatemeh Sadat Yahyapour

Assistant Professor, English Language Department, Faculty of Humanities, Urmia University, Iran

10.22034/ijpie.2023.185570

Abstract

Achilles in the Odyssey prefers being a surf in the land of living to be a king in Hades. His attitude to heroism in The Odyssey contradicts his valorous character in The Iliad. Critics have viewed such contradiction as either a paradoxical rejection of heroism or a pessimistic view of death in general. This paper aims to look at the paradox from a different angle. It is the frozen nature of Hades that Achilles grieves most. In Hades, he is a psyche among other psyches who cannot fulfill any ideal including aristeia or to excel others. Hades is a place of stasis and passivity in sharp contrast to the moving world of the living. Achilles who once strove under the shining sun on the battlefield is now an idle shadow doing nothing. Thus, the stasis in Hades contrasts the strife in the living world and is the cause of Achilles’ paradoxical attitude to heroism.

Keywords

heroism

Hades

stasis

strife

aristeia

Albinus, L. (2000). The House of Hades: Studies in Ancient Greek Eschatology. Per Bilde, Armin W. Geertz, editors. UK: Aarhus University Press.

Beye. C. R. (1966). The ‘Iliad,’ the ‘Odyssey’ and the Epic Tradition. New York: Doubleday.

Clay J. S. (1983). The Wrath of Athena: gods and men in the ‘Odyssey’. Princeton University Press.

Dimakis, N. (2015). “Ancient Greek Deathscapes”. Journal of Eastern Mediterranean Archaeology & Heritage Studies, 3 (1), 27-41.

Frankel H. (1962). Dichtung und Philosophie desfruhen Griechentums. Munich.

Garland, R. (1988). The Greek Way of Death. NY: Cornell University Press.

Gazis, G. A. (2018). Homer and the Poetics of Hades. UK: Oxford University Press.

Graves, R. (1970). Greek Myths. London and New York: Penguin.

Homer. (1990). The Iliad. Translated by Fagles, Robert. NY: Penguin.

Homer. (2009). The Odyssey of Homer. Translated by Richmond Lattimore. Harper Collins ebook.

Keuls E. (1974). The Water Carriers in Hades: A Study of Catharsis through Toil in Classical Antiquity. Amsterdam.

Morris, Ian. (1989). “Attitudes toward Death in Archaic Greece”. Classical Antiquity, 8(2), 296-320.

Redfield, J. M. (1992). Tragedy of Hector—Nature and civilization in Iliad. Athens: Evrialos Publications.

Schmiel Robert. (1987). “Achilles in Hades”. Classical Philology, 82(1), 35-37.

Stanford, W. B. (1974). The ‘Odyssey’, I: Books I–XII. London: Macmillan.

Stewart D. J. (1976). The Disguised Guest: Rank, Role, and Identity in the ‘Odyssey’. Bucknell University Press.

Vernant, J.P. (1991). “A ‘Beautiful Death’ and the Disfigured Corpse in Homeric Epic”. Mortals and Immortals: Collected Essays, by J.P. Vernant. Edited by F. I. Zeitlin. NJ: Princeton University Press, 50-74.